So, I picked up a few nuts at the grocery store yesterday. Peanuts, that is.
And I went straight home and whipped ‘em into perfect shape for this wonder bread recipe I found in my Vita-Mix cookbook.
Ladies and gentleman, fresh from the Fitness & Spice oven I give you…
- 1/2 cup Natural Peanut Butter
- 1/3 cup Sugar (or your favorite sugar substitute)
- 1 1/2 cup Milk (I used unsweetened Almond Milk)
- 1 cup Whole Wheat Flour
- 1 cup All Purpose Flour (I used garbanzo flour because that’s what I had in the house)
- 4 t Baking Powder
- 1 t Salt
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Blend peanut butter, sugar, and milk together. In a separate bowl, combine dry ingredients then add it to the peanut butter mixture, blend. Pour batter into a bread loaf pan coated with non-stick spray. Bake for 45-50 minutes.
You’re probably wondering…
- Will I make this bread again and again? YES!
- Should you top this bread with jelly? Silly question. Next…
- Will I add banana and/or chocolate chips next time? GUARANTEED!
- Will I try it with homemade almond butter? GOOD IDEA!
- Is there any left? Right.
Now I really must go hit the gym and head to work…I’ve got to raise some dough!


Miz says:
April 28th 2010OOOH
I feel as though I say this frequently here but (WAITFORIT) my husband would love this.
love.
Jessica@HowSweet says:
April 28th 2010Um, that is amazing. I want YOU to cook for me!!
Lindsay Cotter says:
April 28th 2010ummm….must make that NOW! I might have to use Amaranth and coconut flour instead to make it GF. Think it’ll work?
Anna @ Newlywed, Newly Veg says:
April 28th 2010Mmmm…sounds delicious! And topping it with jelly…OBVIOUSLY!! :-)
Marisa (Loser for Life) says:
April 28th 2010Oh no, this could be dangerous!!! Wow, that looks fantastic! And I think I have all the ingredients… in…the…kitchen… yikes!!!
Tracey @ I'm Not Superhuman says:
April 28th 2010This sounds so good. My husband would love, love, LOVE this. And double yes to the jelly topping. How could you not?
Jody - Fit at 52 says:
April 28th 2010HOLY CRAP, that looks awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I might eat the whole thing in a sitting too! OH NO! Do you happen to have the nutritional breakdown on it??? I must try but maybe with some substitutions like you!
Kenzie (Healthy Purpose) says:
April 28th 2010That looks really good! I might pass it along to my bread-baking fanatic friend. “Here, make this for me!”
Heather (Wheres the Beach) says:
April 28th 2010Oh wow – YUM. Please send some my way thank you!
Trish @IamSucceeding says:
April 28th 2010So wish I ahd a vit mixer…someday…this looks really good!
Samantha Angela @ Bikini Birthday says:
April 28th 2010oh to have a vitamix! *swoon*
sian-girlgetstrong says:
April 28th 2010Looks so yummy…here I thought this was going to be a post about Wonder Bread brand…pleasant surpirse and new recipe! This one could be dangerous for me…
Lindsey says:
April 28th 2010Oh god. What’s not to like? Peanut butter + bread. In one. I see my week unfolding right before my eyes and it’s going to involve a LOT of this bread.
kalli@fitandfortysomething says:
April 28th 2010so good…..can i come over?
Evan Thomas says:
April 28th 2010This bread sounds delicious! I’m surprised(and delighted) it worked with just chickpea flour
Alyson @ Nourished Fitness says:
April 28th 2010What a fantastic, easy, delicious sounding recipe! PB & Bread?.. only 2 of my favorite things :)
Jodi (jodiojo) says:
April 28th 2010Holy mother of loaves! I love it and I am not a pb kind of girl. Does nothing for me…but the thought of putting jelly on that just made me hyperventilate in my office. Imagine warming that…oh I need to open a window and get some air…lol…;o)
Donna Bush says:
April 28th 2010YUM! My standard banana bread recipe calls for peanut butter. It’s not very healthy, but I bet this would satisfy my craving. Mmmmm … thanks for sharing, J.
april says:
April 28th 2010Oh man, that looks delicious!! But knowing me, I’d top it with even more nut butter!!
Cascia @ Healthy Moms says:
April 28th 2010That looks delicious! I wish I had one of those mixers too.
amanda says:
April 28th 2010Wow that looks sooo yummy!!! LoL I accept all leftovers! :)
Jess (Fit Chick in the City) says:
April 28th 2010First off… you have a vita mix!? I’m so jealous. Secondly, that looks freaking amazing!
Kim says:
April 28th 2010I AM SOOOOO going to make this when I’m done dieting for a show. Just as you and almonds had a break up. I have had to break up with nuts until after my show. =( Nuts are my best friend and I will miss them dearly.
The Candid RD says:
April 28th 2010Seriously?? this is a GREAT recipe!! And there is such thing as garbanzo flour?? That’s crazy. What’s crazier is that I have never made my own nut butter. I need to get on top of that, pronto.
Kat says:
April 28th 2010Oh. My. Goodness.
Possibly because I just did 40 miles on the bike, but that looks amazing! Pretty sure I’d scarf half of it in one sitting though! Peanut Butter is my kryptonite, gotta be careful with it.
FatFighterTV says:
April 28th 2010Garbanzo flour? Never heard of it. I must try it! That bread looks fab!
Lily @ Lily's Health Pad says:
April 29th 2010Wow, this sounds so good! I want to try garbonzo flour!
Lani says:
April 29th 2010Yum! I wish I could keep up with you.
Protein Powder & Jelly Chia | Fitness & Spice says:
May 10th 2010[...] you think chia jelly would be good on that Peanut Butter Bread? Brilliant [...]
Sir Mix A Lot | Fitness & Spice says:
May 20th 2010[...] quality and the price tag. But just think of all of the money I’ll save making my own peanut butter, frappaccinos, lemonade, soup, salad dressing, ice cream, sorbet, breads, protein shakes, salsas, [...]
I Dream of Peanut Butter « Foodie on the Rocks says:
May 24th 2010[...] And finally, this afternoon, I baked the best bread ever. I made peanut butter bread. If you’re drooling on your keyboard right now, your imagination is dead on. Go ahead. Keep drooling. Or you can just scroll down a little further and take a glimpse at the glorious combination of peanut butter and flour. I grabbed the recipe from this butt kickin’ blog. [...]
Kulture Dump says:
June 4th 2010Jason Kidd Loves His Wonderbread!…
I found your entry interesting do I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…