I like my iced coffee like my personal trainers, strong and not bitter. So when I discovered a better way to make iced coffee I was pumped.
I used to just make iced coffee by brewing a pot of coffee and pouring it over ice—the result? Cold, bitter coffee. Not grande. Now I make the perfect pitcher of iced coffee in just 3 easy steps…
- Combine 1/2 pound of coarsely chopped coffee beans with 5 cups water and let it sit for 12 hours (not hard and yes you can double this recipe)
- Strain coffee into a pitcher using a colander lined with cheesecloth, a coffee filter, or a paper napkin (right, Carrie?)
- Pour over ice and dilute with additional water or your favorite milk to taste (an important step as this brew will be venti strong!)
Now let’s address your questions:
- What if I like my iced coffee like my personal trainer…a little sweeter? Then it’s time to get a new trainer! Kidding! To sweeten the pot, simply add a little natural sweetener like stevia and/or a tablespoon or two of your favorite protein powder.
- I can’t possibly drink the entire pitcher in one day how long will it keep? You can store the coffee in the fridge for a good week or two, maybe even three.
- My doctor suggested that I limit my caffeine. Will decaf coffee work? Silly question.
- Are there health benefits to drinking coffee? Great question! I am not a doctor, but I asked WebMD and a few other sources and discovered there have been many studies about the perks of coffee including its benefits to athletic performance and recovery. Here’s what Dr. Terry Graham has to say on the subject…
” …[caffeine] signals you to ignore fatigue or recruit extra units of muscle for intense athletic performance. Caffeine may even have a direct effect on muscles themselves, causing them to produce a stronger contraction. But what’s amazing about it is that unlike some performance-enhancing manipulation some athletes do that are specific for strength or sprinting or endurance, studies show that caffeine positively enhances all of these things.”
[Disclaimer: Talk to your doctor about caffeine and drink responsibly]
- But what if I don’t like coffee? This does not surprise me. I just read this statistic on Livestrong.com that only 54% of people in the U.S. drink coffee everyday. I don’t get it. But to answer your question, I suppose if you are one of the people that can pass up a cup of coffee, you can pass this recipe on to 54% of your friends.
Now I really must go grab a cup of coffee, my trainer said we’re going to hit the grounds running!


Kasia says:
August 3rd 2010i’m a shameless Starbuck addict, and coffee addict firstly. Thirsty for cold brew; much more satisfyin’ than the hot stuff which tends to put me to sleep. So thanks for the recepie and i enjoy the tall play on silly coffee language. Venti nice, indeed!
Miz says:
August 3rd 2010have you ever had TODDY COFFEE?
you would weep at its smooooooth iced delight ;)
Anna @ Newlywed, Newly Veg says:
August 3rd 2010Oooh, thank you for this! I love iced coffee, but I always buy it! Now I can make my own :-)
Efi says:
August 3rd 2010That is a nice tip. In my country we love iced coffee
Marisa @Loser for Life says:
August 3rd 2010Yes! I love the cold brew method! I’ve been using it with my french press and it works great. Very smooth tasting. And yes, caffeine does indeed, ROCK ;)
Jody - Fit at 52 says:
August 3rd 2010That is such a cool recipe. THX!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Tweets that mention Perfect Iced Coffee in 3 Easy Steps | Fitness & Spice -- Topsy.com says:
August 3rd 2010[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Donna Bush, Joanna Sutter. Joanna Sutter said: Find out how my iced coffee recipe is like my personal trainer today on Fitness & Spice… http://fb.me/FWJriFyb [...]
Estela @ Weekly Bite says:
August 3rd 2010Thanks for the recipe! I’ve always just poured my brewed coffee over ice. I’m totally trying this next time :)
Tracey @ I'm Not Superhuman says:
August 3rd 2010I love that Starbucks cup (in your photo). It’s the greatest, sweat-free cup ever. I never make homemade iced coffee (I’m an iced tea girl), but 54% of my friends say thank you for the tips.
Kris | iheartwellness.com says:
August 3rd 2010I love making my coffee like this! This is just like the cold water process and it is like 70% less acid! Perfection!
PS. I think you are an amazing writer! This is your passion girl!
xxoo
Patty says:
August 3rd 2010Sounds like an easy recipe!! I’ve been looking for an easier and quicker way to make iced coffee – Thanks! Do you recommend a specific brand for the 1/2 pound of coarsely chopped coffee beans? Also, do the 5 cups of water need to be at a specific temperature? When you say “let it sit for 12 hours”, does the pitcher need to be sitting at room temperature or put in the fridge? Sorry to bother you with these questions! I’m really looking forward to making the “perfect” iced coffee :)
jen says:
August 3rd 2010WOW! Those 54% of non-coffee-drinkers must be miserable. LOVE LOVE LOVE ME some good ice coffee :) will give your method a try!
Deb says:
August 3rd 2010I’m one of the 56% who do not like coffee and, as a result, I’ve been told I make terrible coffee! Thanks for a recipe I can follow and serve to my guests!
The Candid RD says:
August 3rd 2010Wow, this is so unlike how I typically do it! I usually make my coffee a day ahead, then put it in the fridge. Then when it’s nice and cold, I pour it over ice! Your method sounds very interesting, and I have a feeling the coffee would be a bit stronger (yeah!). Sounds so good right now…at 9:45 pm, ha.
Pure2Raw Twins says:
August 3rd 2010Iced coffee sounds great. Perfect for a hot summer day!
FatFighterTV says:
August 3rd 2010I am in that stat with the people who don’t drink/like coffee. Yep, that’s me. But you know I love my tea, hold the caffeine please.
Healthy Living is Contagious | Fitness & Spice says:
August 5th 2010[...] I was reading along, I nearly spit out my coffee. In a nutshell, the article explained that in addition to a great workout you can also get boils, [...]